And oops… I guessed I would be showing my ignorance with the comments about slide guitar as soon as I wrote that I didn’t like it. Still don’t like it but in keeping with the history of the band I totally accept that it actually does have a place in the current lineup.

But we will have to remain in disagreement about Muddy’s style. I actually think Joe is keeping up the rhythm section exceptionally well, but certainly at Kidlington it still looked like Muddy was looking for approval rather than fitting in seamlessly and I couldn’t see much connection between Andy and he. I realise Ben brought a whole different interpretation and presence – it seemed to gel with my own preferences, so I do accept I am lamenting the departure of Ben rather than the arrival of Muddy. But long live Wishbone Ash – the very fact that the band still exists is true testament to all those involved both past and present.

The Kidlington gig was not the best of the tour, fitted in at short notice, poor acoustics, tight stage etc

I can’t agree with your views on Muddy – certainly not as flambuoyant as Ben (who is a great mate) but a well rounded player and worthy holder of the twin guitar slot. Andy has described him as the closest to Ted Turner but with more chops – so can’t be bad.

Remember Ted used a lap steel so actually Muddy doing so is back to the original authenticity – Muddy also plays slide.